| Season | Award | Reason | First Name | Last Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Captain of the Year | Bryan | Sinski | |
| 1 | Defenseman of the Year | Bruce | Hall | |
| 1 | Goalie of the Year | Dustin | Marum | |
| 1 | Golden Stick | Most Assists | Bruce | Hall |
| 1 | Ironman Award | Most Shots & Blocks Combined | Zach | Walker |
| 1 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Matt | Chester |
| 1 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Bruce | Hall |
| 1 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Michael | Rekhopf |
| 1 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Connor | Davis |
| 1 | Playoff MVP | Joe | Hemberger | |
| 1 | Rookie of the Year | Best New Player | Regan | DeLuca |
| 1 | Seana Marum Award | Dedication to the League | Evan | Barlow |
| 1 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Bryan | Sinski |
| 1 | Walker Award | Most Valuable Player | Bryan | Sinski |
| 2 | Captain of the Year | Bryan | Sinski | |
| 2 | Defenseman of the Year | Brandon | Hall | |
| 2 | Goalie of the Year | Joe | Hemberger | |
| 2 | Golden Stick | Most Assists | Matt | Roza |
| 2 | Golden Stick | Most Assists | Marc | Allison |
| 2 | Ironman Award | Most Shots & Blocks Combined | Zach | Walker |
| 2 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Manny | Gacity |
| 2 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Rob | Vanacore |
| 2 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Regan | DeLuca |
| 2 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Joe | Roma |
| 2 | Playoff MVP | Justin | Dayock | |
| 2 | Rookie of the Year | Best New Player | Mark | Short |
| 2 | Seana Marum Award | Dedication to the League | Bryan | Sinski |
| 2 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Justin | Bradley |
| 2 | Walker Award | Most Valuable Player | Zach | Walker |
| 3 | Captain of the Year | David | Andras | |
| 3 | Defenseman of the Year | Cody | Hall | |
| 3 | Goalie of the Year | Joe | Hemberger | |
| 3 | Golden Stick | Most Assists | Mike | Costa |
| 3 | Ironman Award | Most Shots & Blocks Combined | Zach | Walker |
| 3 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Jason | Pool |
| 3 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Kyle | Morgan |
| 3 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Mike | Costa |
| 3 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Sean | Stewart |
| 3 | Most Improved Player | Thomas | Cione | |
| 3 | Most Improved Player | Manny | Gacity | |
| 3 | Post Season MVP | Brad | Sinski | |
| 3 | Rookie of the Year | Best New Player | Phil | Thompson |
| 3 | Seana Marum Award | Dedication to the League | Andrew | Call |
| 3 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Zach | Walker |
| 3 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Bryan | Sinski |
| 3 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Evan | Barlow |
| 3 | Walker Award | Most Valuable Player | Marc | Allison |
| 4 | Captain of the Year | David | Andras | |
| 4 | Defenseman of the Year | Chandler | Sheldon | |
| 4 | Goalie of the Year | Justin | Dayock | |
| 4 | Golden Stick | Most Assists | Zach | Walker |
| 4 | Ironman Award | Most Shots & Blocks Combined | Brad | Sinski |
| 4 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Joe | Hemberger |
| 4 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Austin | Rumer |
| 4 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Justin | Lawrence |
| 4 | Marum Award | Sportsmanship | Seth | Blasko |
| 4 | Most Improved Player | Mark | Short | |
| 4 | Post Season MVP | Brendan | Murphy | |
| 4 | Rookie of the Year | Best New Player | Joe | Campanelli |
| 4 | Seana Marum Award | Dedication to the League | David | Andras |
| 4 | Top Goal Scorer | Most Goals | Brad | Sinski |
| 4 | Walker Award | Most Valuable Player | Brad | Sinski |